Question: Is this actually worth the reader’s time?
The article must identify a real shift, pattern, risk, or opportunity. Not noise. Not filler. Not a summary of random updates.
Pass looks like
- One clear thesis
- One meaningful shift
- One reason the reader should care now
Question: Can a smart reader follow this without getting lost?
The article should simplify without dumbing down. Complex ideas must be translated into plain language, strong structure, and readable flow.
Pass looks like
- Strong headline and sharp TLDR
- Logical section order
- No jargon pileup or vague abstractions
Question: Is this grounded, accurate, and honest?
Claims must be supportable. If something is inferred, frame it as inference. If something is uncertain, say so. Hype is not a substitute for evidence.
Pass looks like
- Facts are checked
- Assumptions are visible
- Hype is avoided and uncertainty stated clearly
Question: Does this connect to real work and real people?
Every article should answer why this matters for consultants, operators, executives, founders, or anyone doing serious work with AI.
Pass looks like
- Practical implications stated clearly
- Real-world examples or scenarios
- Clear explanation of what changes at work
Question: Did we push past the first obvious answer?
The article should not stop at surface commentary. It needs second-order thinking, named failure modes, and deeper interpretation of what is actually happening.
Pass looks like
- Moves beyond product release notes
- Identifies failure modes and tradeoffs
- Explores what happens next
Question: Is this easy to absorb and visually coherent?
The article must be designed for attention, not just written for it. Pacing, visual breaks, diagrams, pull-lines, and spacing all matter as much as the words.
Pass looks like
- Strong reading rhythm with visual resets
- Custom diagrams where the idea needs them
- No walls of text. Memorable pull-lines.
Question: Does the reader leave with something useful?
Every article should leave the reader with one move to steal, one lens to keep, or one practical next step they can act on by Monday morning.
Pass looks like
- A named, practical takeaway
- A clear “what to do now”
- A reason to come back for the next issue
Predicai article standard
A Signal issue should only publish if it can honestly say:
This matters. This is true. This is clear. This applies to real work. This goes deeper than the surface. This is well designed. This gives the reader a move.
All seven. Every time.